...that doesn't narrow it down much. Bottle of Youth, Hero Sigil, Ditto-themed Switch... [he frowns a little. or maybe he doesn't. i don't know how aware we are of each other's cyoa rewards like i know we talked about who got what oocly but i don't know when icly that would have happened] Shoujo Manga, Cleansing Leaf Concoction, Bouquet of Flowers, Shiny Charm, Better with Faces, Personal Radio, and Pink Ribbon I don't remember seeing on these lists or having myself.

Bottle of Youth seems like - oh. If we're going off the names, maybe that's what happened to Ace earlier in the week...